"Chef John Correa marries French sauces to reef-caught hogfish at Café Solé — book it for a romantic Old Town dinner."
Café Solé sits on a quiet corner off Duval Street at 1029 Southard Street, in Old Town Key West, and is led by chef John Correa. He pairs his French training in classic sauces with the island's locally landed seafood — a combination that won People's Choice and Best Entrée at the Master Chefs Classic. The house motto sums it up: "God made the fish, we just cook it right."
The signature is reef-caught hogfish — the Hogfish Snapper Solé, pan-seared and finished with a roasted red-pepper hollandaise (around $45). Nightly specials run to mutton snapper in pesto and champagne and yellowtail in a lobster beurre blanc, with the French-Caribbean crossover carried through bouillabaisse and a respected wine list. Divers land much of the fish, so the catch drives the board. Mains sit in the upper-mid range for Key West.
The room is intimate and unshowy — a small, candlelit space with a courtyard feel, tucked away from the Duval crowds. It reads as a date-night and special-occasion address rather than a casual drop-in, and the service matches: attentive, knowledgeable about the catch, and happy to talk through the night's specials.
For an anniversary, a proposal or a romantic dinner in Key West, Café Solé is the off-Duval choice: chef John Correa's French-Caribbean cooking, reef-caught hogfish and a quiet, candlelit room. A natural anniversary table.
Not for a rowdy, casual night out on Duval or a quick cheap bite — Café Solé is a small, intimate French-Caribbean room geared to a slower, special-occasion dinner.
Café Solé is led by chef John Correa, who pairs classic French sauce technique with locally landed Florida Keys seafood. The combination won People's Choice and Best Entrée at the Master Chefs Classic.
Café Solé is at 1029 Southard Street, just off Duval Street in Old Town Key West, Florida — a quiet corner away from the main strip.
The signature is reef-caught hogfish — the Hogfish Snapper Solé, pan-seared with a roasted red-pepper hollandaise (around $45). Nightly specials include mutton snapper in pesto and champagne.
Yes. Its small, candlelit room off Duval, attentive service and French-Caribbean seafood make it one of Key West's strongest choices for an anniversary, proposal or date night.
Reservations are recommended. The room is intimate with limited tables, so booking ahead — especially in high season — is the safest way to secure a dinner table.
Booking via OpenTable; we may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Affiliate disclosure: Restaurants for Kings may earn a commission when you book through our reservation links, at no cost to you. Our scores are editorial and never paid for.
See where Café Solé ranks among Key West's tables, sorted by the occasion you're booking.
Read the Key West guide →